Skip to content

Sole Trader vs Employee: What's Best for Support Workers?

Estimated Reading Time: 2mins

Quick Answer

There is no single “best” option for every support worker. As an employee, you work for an employer and receive employment rights and entitlements that apply to your role. As a sole trader, you run your own business, usually choose your clients and fees, and manage your own invoicing, tax, records and business costs. The right option depends on how you want to work and, importantly, the true nature of the working arrangement.

Sole Trader vs Employee: What's the Difference?

An employee works in another business under an employment arrangement. Their employer generally manages payroll, withholds tax and makes required super contributions. Employees also have minimum workplace rights and entitlements under Australian employment law.

A sole trader is running their own business. Independent contractors generally negotiate their fees and working arrangements and may work for more than one client. They are responsible for business administration such as invoicing, record keeping and managing their tax obligations.

Having an ABN or sending invoices does not automatically make someone an independent contractor.

Sole Trader vs Employee: What's Best for Support Workers?

What Are the Benefits of Being an Employee?

Employment may suit support workers who prefer more of their work administration and employment obligations to be managed by an employer.

Depending on the type of employment, benefits can include:

  • Minimum employment entitlements
  • Employer-managed PAYG tax withholding
  • Employer super contributions
  • Paid leave for eligible permanent employees
  • Less invoicing and business administration
  • Greater certainty around agreed hours or ongoing work in some roles

Casual employees have different entitlements from permanent employees, including casual loading instead of some paid leave entitlements.

What Are the Benefits of Working as a Sole Trader?

Working independently may suit support workers who want to run their own business and have greater control over the way they provide their services.

A genuine independent contractor may be able to:

  • Choose which clients they work with
  • Negotiate their own fees
  • Set or negotiate working arrangements
  • Work with multiple clients
  • Build their own support business

With that independence comes responsibility. Sole traders need to manage their own invoicing, business records, tax and expenses. Contractors may also need to arrange their own insurance and super, although some contractors can still be entitled to super contributions when they are paid mainly for their labour.

Can I Choose Whether I'm an Employee or Sole Trader?

Not simply by choosing a label. Whether you are legally an employee or independent contractor depends on the working relationship and the test that applies.

Factors can include who controls how the work is performed, who carries financial risk, who supplies equipment, whether work can be delegated, how working hours are set and whether there is an expectation of ongoing work.

A business cannot avoid employee obligations simply by calling a worker a contractor or requiring them to get an ABN. Sham contracting is illegal.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do sole trader support workers get paid super?

Independent contractors often manage their own super, but some contractors may still be entitled to super contributions if they are paid mainly for their labour. The individual arrangement needs to be checked against current ATO rules.

An ABN does not determine whether you are a contractor. If the true working arrangement is employment, simply calling it contracting or requiring an ABN does not change that. Misrepresenting an employee as a contractor can be sham contracting.

Yes. A person can be an employee in one working relationship and operate their own business separately. Each arrangement needs to be treated according to its own circumstances, including tax, record-keeping and employment obligations.

How Earni Helps

For support workers who choose to run their own business, Earni helps keep invoicing, client details, appointments and business records organised in one place. This can make the extra administration that comes with working independently easier to manage.